Posts tagged “Commentaries

Commentaries are (mostly) worthless

Posted on November 1st, 2012

This observation by T. Desmond Alexander succinctly explains the problem with most modern commentaries: Studying the biblical texts by means of commentaries can be compared to looking at the separate pieces of a jigsaw puzzle. Though we may find something of interest in each piece, it is only when all the pieces are put together that we get the complete picture…. By atomizing the text and considering each unit independently, there is ever present the danger of misinterpreting these shorter passages. While I was in seminary, I overheard a pastor saying, “If I could go through seminary again, I’d buy fewer commentaries and more theological works.” I now understand what he meant. Commentaries don’t really help you preach, or teach. If you want a…

The sin of excessive inquisitiveness

Posted on May 15th, 2012

Luther, commenting on how many fathers say nothing about Lot’s wife being turned into a pillar of salt, while others relate ridiculous ideas, says in AE 3: Perhaps this happened through the extraordinary providence of God, in order that we may keep reading the sacred books and not merely be occupied with reading the commentaries of human beings, who often sin through their excessive inquisitiveness.