Posts tagged “Law (civil)

Questions about Law, Government Power, and the Church

Posted on May 22nd, 2012

The sad story of the Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod’s Minnesota South District [MNS] selling University Lutheran Chapel [ULC] and planned eviction of the congregation there took another turn, with MNS supposedly serving eviction papers on ULC (reference here, but no documentation). There is a substantial discussion about the propriety of ULC suing MNS between Pastor David Kind and Pastor Mark Surburg, which you can read here. Here is my question: Do those who allege that ULC is wrong to sue MNS (on the grounds of 1 Cor. 6, which instructs Christians not to take each other to court) also believe it is wrong for MNS to use the courts and temporal powers to force the congregation out of its church? Isn’t that the same problem,…

The dark underbelly of the Hosanna-Tabor v EEOC case

Posted on January 17th, 2012

Among Christians in general, and LCMS insiders in particular, there has been great rejoicing over the Hosanna-Tabor v EEOC case. While glad for a clear victory for religious liberty, and the right of churches to choose their ministers, the outcome bothered me for a variety of reasons. I hadn’t shared that dismay too widely, but was delighted to hear Todd Wilken on the Issues, Etc. radio program voice his concerns with his usual concision and passion. A summary: The case demonstrates deep problems in the LCMS dispute resolution process It weakens the status of church employees in the LCMS The church shows an inability to admit any fault, instead hiding behind lawyers and the courts The church shows it is inclined not to care…