
The Impressive Clergyman
There’s an interesting discussion here at Rev’d McCain’s blog about whether or not there is an “ideal” Lutheran form of worship, in the comments to a post that warns us of “The High Church Danger to the Lutheran Church.” As best as I can tell, the warning is against the liturgical practice of a departed brother who is now a priest in the Antiochian church, whose order of service was never removed from the church website. Yet McCain seems to suggest a movement of high church pastors and churches, which is a great surprise to me, since I feel virtually alone out here in the Lutheran wilderness.
Truly our Confessions give wide latitude regarding ceremony. Yet is there really no ideal form of practice? Paul McCain says, “There is no ideal.” I am convinced that our Confessions assume an ideal, and it’s articulated in AC XXIV:
Our churches are falsely accused of abolishing the Mass. The Mass is held among us and celebrated with the highest reverence. Nearly all the usual ceremonies are also preserved, except that the parts sung in Latin are interspersed here and there with German hymns…. All those able to do so partake of the Sacrament together. This also increases the reverence and devotion of public worship…. The people are also advised about the dignity and use of the Sacrament, about how it brings great consolation to anxious consciences, so that they may learn to believe God and to expect and ask from Him all that is good. This worship pleases God. Such use of the Sacrament nourishes true devotion toward God. Therefore, it does not appear that the Mass is more devoutly celebrated among our adversaries than among us.
The Apology adds to this:
At the outset, we must again make this preliminary statement: we do not abolish the Mass, but religiously keep and defend it. Masses are celebrated among us every Lord’s Day and on the other festivals. The Sacrament is offered to those who wish to use it, after they have been examined and absolved. And the usual public ceremonies are observed, the series of lessons, of prayers, vestments, and other such things. (McCain translation)
One of my goals as a Lutheran pastor has been to actually live out what those words say in the liturgical practice of my parish. What I have discovered is that simply doing what is in the hymnal, along with the terrible Romish sins of crossing yourself and kneeling, will get you branded by your fellow pastors with the scarlet (or rose?) letters HC: “High Church,” a great wickedness which everyone knows is tearing the Synod apart. Gadzooks, how these chasuble-wearing chanters are proliferating!
Well, I’m ready to take this to the next level: If there’s a dangerous, secret cabal of High Church Lutherans actually trying to do what our Confessions say, this is my semaphore: Brethren, contact me! I’d like to join your merry band of idealists. We can be troublers of Israel together.